OMAHA (DTN) — A potential supply chain disruption on the Mississippi River could affect 7.2 million tons of commodities valued at $2.8 billion in the month of January, according to updated economic figures released by an industry group.
The river level near Thebes, Ill., is projected to fall to 8 feet between Jan. 5 and 15, effectively shutting down river traffic because most tug boats need at least 9 feet of water to operate. The Army Corps of Engineers won’t officially close the river.
“The uncertainty of this deteriorating situation for the nation’s shippers is having as much of an impact as the lack of water itself,” said Michael J. Toohey, WCI’s president and CEO, in a press release. According to a study released Wednesday by the Waterways Council, Inc. and the American Waterways Operators, there are 8,000 jobs and $54 million in wages and benefits on the line in addition to lost shipping traffic.
The updated estimates do not take into account economic damage during the month of December, when the water fight between states in the Missouri River basin and the lower Mississippi River states started boiling. On Nov. 30, the groups estimated that a river closure would displace $7 billion of commodities including grains, coal, petroleum and chemicals.
“It’s hard to get a real figure on what the actual disruption has been,” Waterways Council spokesperson Debra Colbert told DTN. “Companies are very reluctant to talk about how much it’s costing them, but it’s having a major impact. For example, one company told me it cost them $50 million worth of business because of light loading and cancellations.”
Colbert said subtracting January’s estimate from the combined estimate issued in November is the best way to get a rough estimate of the economic impact. That puts the cost of uncertain water levels at $4.2 billion in December.
“At the end of it all, whenever that end is in sight, we should be able to say a lot more confidently what the economic impact of this was,” Colbert said, noting there are research and survey methods — such as anonymous surveys — that can be used after the fact that make businesses more comfortable disclosing losses.
The Army Corps began excavating and blasting rock pinnacle formations near Thebes, Ill., in December. Barges have an eight-hour window to pass through the area each day while the removal is taking place. Colbert said the rock removal is scheduled to be completed by the end of January, but it’s possible that it could extend into February.
The waterways groups continue to urge President Barack Obama to step into the conflict by directing the Army Corps to release more water from Missouri River reservoirs. The corps’ Missouri River operations manual prevents it from managing the Missouri River to benefit the Mississippi River. Missouri River reservoir levels are also low because of this summer’s crippling drought, and groups from those states have petitioned the president to stand by the corps, citing the water’s importance for hydro-power production, ice management and tourism, one of the top industries outside of agriculture in Montana and the Dakotas.
A river conditions report released by a large shipping group notes that the upper Mississippi and Midwest need ongoing rains to fix the water level problem in the long term.
“The water between St. Louis and Cairo is low enough that minor fluctuations in weather or water flow rates can be the difference between the river closing or remaining open,” the report said. “The corps has released water from upstream reservoirs, which is still a temporary stave-off fix. There have been storms passing through the Midwest, which has created snow in a majority of the area. That is good for much-needed ground moisture once melt occurs but not much immediate help for river levels.”